Does a Hail Cannon Actually Cease the Hail?

CUAUHTÉMOC, MEXICO — Because the early Eighties, farmer Carlos Pérez has relied on a hail cannon to guard the apple orchards which were in his household for 3 generations.

Perched on a corrugated steel outhouse, Pérez’s hail cannon is a 3-meter (10-foot) gadget that resembles a steel funnel. When turned on, it emits explosive booms, blasting shock waves into the ambiance. The gadget is designed to disrupt the formation of doubtless damaging hailstones earlier than and through storms.

For many years, farmers and fruit growers like Pérez have trusted these units to protect their crops, regardless of an absence of scientific proof that they work. Environmental campaigners argue that there’s a hyperlink between the usage of these cannons and a discount in rainfall, additionally with out vital proof. Native and state governments are reluctant to resolve if they need to be permitted, leaving many farmers not sure as to whether or not they can use them.

In 2019, the municipal president of Cuauhtémoc, the native governing physique, instructed Pérez that he couldn’t use his hail cannon till he might current a research on the environmental affect at his personal expense, one thing the 65-year-old orchard proprietor is unwilling to fund every time he needs to make use of the machine. Three years later, officers in Cuauhtémoc nonetheless require hail cannon customers to close down their machines and fund their very own research. Along with his hail cannon out of motion, Pérez says, his orchards are in danger.

He recollects one of many situations when his hail cannon “labored completely.”

“I used to be very nervous as a result of the hail was so robust,” he says, including that he rushed out to activate the cannon and witnessed the hail stones “disappearing” as they approached the perimeter of the cannon, as an alternative falling “like snow.”

Farmers have been placing climate management strategies to the check for a whole lot of years to maintain their livelihoods intact. Hail cannons have continued to evolve, regardless of some authorities’ unwillingness to take a agency stance on the machines.

A hail cannon blasts shock waves into the ambiance. It is meant to disrupt the formation of damaging hailstones, though lacks a lot scientific proof. Video by Lilette A. Contreras, GPJ Mexico

One hailstorm has the potential to break hundreds of hectares of crops. In July 2019, greater than 5,000 hectares (19 sq. miles) of crops have been broken after a hailstorm hit Zapotlán del Rey, Jalisco, in west central Mexico, with 2,500 hectares (10 sq. miles) deemed a whole loss for farmers.

Pérez, who lives within the northwestern state of Chihuahua, the place the danger of hailstorms varies, now must depend on hail netting, a cloth internet that gives a protecting layer over his crops. It’s an added value and frustration whereas his hail cannon sits idle.

The unpredictability of devastating climate is a continuing concern for all farmers, however these units may be an excessive and costly resolution. Pérez says his grandfather purchased the hail cannon in 1983 from Germany. Pérez doesn’t recall how a lot it value, however a producer in New Zealand, which provides the units to farms and companies world wide, sells them for round $40,000.

expand slideshow

Graphic by Matt Haney, GPJ

Precisely how many individuals have these cannons is unknown. Marcial Reyes Cázarez, everlasting marketing consultant for the Ministry of the Setting, Local weather Change and Territorial Improvement in western Mexico’s Michoacán state, says it has 1,200 such units.

Relationship again over 100 years and thought to have been first utilized by French farmers to guard their vineyards, hail cannons reemerged within the latter a part of the Nineteen Nineties, regardless of there being no “scientific foundation nor a reputable speculation to assist” them, based on a report by the World Meteorological Group in 2001. The identical yr, the Fee of Rural Improvement, underneath the Chihuahua state legislature, decided there wasn’t sufficient scientific proof to ban or prohibit the usage of hail cannons. Greater than 20 years after this report, many governing our bodies throughout Mexico, together with Pérez’s municipality of Cuauhtémoc, nonetheless haven’t determined whether or not to allow hail cannons.

Irma de la Peña, Cuauhtémoc’s head of ecology, says she has analyzed the arguments for and in opposition to and is unable to take a place, admitting that either side lack scientific proof.

“Everybody has stated the identical factor: There aren’t any research that show something … no scientific research wherever,” de la Peña says.

expand slideshow


Carlos Pérez’s son, Carlos Pérez Hernández, activates the hail cannon, which sits in his father’s apple orchard close to Cuauhtémoc, Mexico.

In 2017, nonetheless, Reyes Cázarez used a rain measuring software known as a pluviometer and a sound degree meter, which measures the depth of rainfall, to show that there was a relationship between the hail cannon explosions, attributable to a mixture of gases, and a discount within the quantity of rainfall.

The potential hyperlink between the cannon’s use and fewer rainfall is exacerbated by an intense and widespread drought throughout practically 85% of Mexico, based on the NASA Earth Observatory, run by the US authorities, with restoration hampered by a drier than regular January this yr.

The Colectivo Ambiental Diente de León, an environmental rights marketing campaign group based by residents of San Salvador el Seco, in Puebla, an space with one of many highest threats of hailstorms, was so involved with the attainable hyperlink between the usage of these cannons and a discount in rainfall, members despatched an official grievance to the Ministry of the Setting, Sustainable Improvement and Land Administration of Puebla state.

Hail cannons are already banned in that state, in addition to the western states of Michoacán and Colima, however the collective claims they’re nonetheless being utilized in Puebla, regardless of the ban.

expand slideshow


Orchard proprietor Carlos Pérez says he has to depend on hail netting after the governing physique of Cuauhtémoc instructed him he couldn’t use his hail cannon.

Collective member Gerardo Romero Bartolo says that following their grievance, two officers from the setting division visited the areas the place the collective stated hail cannons have been put to make use of. They detected no hail cannon use, one thing the collective blames on the inspection being carried out within the fall, when hailstorms are unlikely.

The Ministry of the Setting, Sustainable Improvement and Land Administration of the State of Puebla didn’t reply to requests for remark.

Three years after he was pressured to cease the usage of his nearly 40-year-old hail cannon, Pérez vows not to surrender his struggle to make use of the gadget he and his household have relied on for many years.

Supply hyperlink